Jenny Han’s We’ll Always Have Summer delivers a powerful and emotionally charged finale to the beloved Summer trilogy, forcing readers to confront the messy reality that sometimes love isn’t enough to sustain a relationship. After following Belly Conklin through her tumultuous journey of first love, heartbreak, and self-discovery across The Summer I Turned Pretty and It’s Not Summer Without You, this third installment presents the most mature and complex exploration of love, choice, and consequence in the series.
The novel opens with Belly as a college freshman, seemingly settled in her relationship with Jeremiah Fisher. Two years have passed since Conrad told her to “go with Jeremiah,” and on the surface, everything appears to be working out as planned. However, Han masterfully peels back the layers to reveal the cracks in what should have been a fairy-tale ending, demonstrating her growth as a writer in tackling the uncomfortable truths about relationships that young adult fiction often glosses over.
The Weight of Betrayal and Forgiveness
The central conflict emerges when Belly discovers Jeremiah’s infidelity during their brief spring break separation. Han handles this revelation with remarkable nuance, avoiding the temptation to paint Jeremiah as a villain or Belly as a naive victim. Instead, she explores the complex emotions that arise when someone you trust implicitly breaks that trust, and the even more complicated question of whether forgiveness and moving forward are possible.
Jeremiah’s betrayal with Lacie Barone during the Cabo trip serves as more than just a plot device—it becomes a catalyst for Belly to examine what she truly wants from love and partnership. The author’s decision to have this infidelity occur during a time when Belly and Jeremiah were technically “broken up” adds layers of moral ambiguity that reflect real-world relationship complications. The pain isn’t just about the physical act of cheating; it’s about the realization that their connection wasn’t as unbreakable as Belly believed.
Character Development and Emotional Maturity
Han’s character development shines brightest in this final installment. Belly’s journey from the uncertain teenager of the first book to a young woman grappling with life-altering decisions feels authentic and earned. Her internal conflict between choosing security with Jeremiah versus the passionate but unpredictable love she shares with Conrad reflects the universal struggle between what feels safe and what feels true.
Conrad’s character arc reaches its most compelling point as he grapples with his own demons while watching the woman he loves prepare to marry his brother. Han skillfully portrays his internal torment without excusing his past behavior, creating a character who is simultaneously frustrating and sympathetic. His late-night confession to Belly on the beach before her wedding represents both his greatest moment of vulnerability and his most selfish act.
Jeremiah, meanwhile, transforms from the golden boy of the earlier books into a more complex figure struggling with his own insecurities and the weight of being “second choice.” His anger and hurt feel genuine, and Han doesn’t shy away from showing how even the kindest people can become bitter when faced with rejection.
The Complexities of Family Dynamics
One of the novel’s greatest strengths lies in its exploration of family relationships under stress. The Fisher and Conklin families, bound together by decades of shared summers and Susannah’s memory, face the potential destruction of their bonds through Belly’s romantic choices. Han expertly navigates the delicate balance between personal happiness and family loyalty, showing how individual decisions ripple through entire networks of relationships.
Laurel’s reaction to the engagement feels particularly authentic—a mother struggling between supporting her daughter’s autonomy and protecting her from what she sees as a mistake. The wedding planning sequences highlight the tension between youthful idealism and parental wisdom, with neither side portrayed as entirely right or wrong.
Narrative Structure and Pacing Challenges
While Han’s emotional storytelling remains strong, the novel’s pacing occasionally suffers under the weight of its complex setup. The wedding preparation sequences, while necessary for building tension, sometimes feel drawn out compared to the more dynamic beach house scenes that made the earlier books so memorable. The multiple perspective shifts, including Conrad’s point of view, add depth but occasionally disrupt the narrative flow that made Belly’s voice so compelling in previous installments.
The climactic wedding day sequence, however, showcases Han at her finest. The mounting tension, family dynamics, and emotional revelations converge in a beautifully orchestrated crescendo that honors both the characters’ growth and the series’ themes.
Themes of Choice and Self-Discovery
At its core, We’ll Always Have Summer is about the power and burden of choice. Han explores how our decisions shape not only our own lives but the lives of everyone around us. Belly’s ultimate realization that she cannot divide her heart indefinitely speaks to the necessity of making difficult choices even when there are no perfect options.
The novel also examines the difference between loving someone and being able to build a life with them. Belly’s love for both Fisher brothers is never questioned, but Han forces her (and readers) to confront whether love alone is sufficient for a lasting partnership.
Writing Style and Emotional Resonance
Han’s prose maintains the accessible, emotionally immediate style that has made her such a beloved author in the young adult space. Her ability to capture the intensity of teenage and young adult emotions without diminishing their validity remains one of her greatest strengths. The beach house setting continues to serve as both backdrop and character, with the ocean metaphorically representing the ebb and flow of relationships and the constancy of memory.
The incorporation of Susannah’s letter provides a touching connection to the series’ emotional foundation while offering wisdom that transcends the immediate romantic conflicts. These moments showcase Han’s skill at weaving together past and present to create meaning that extends beyond the central love triangle.
Series Conclusion: Satisfying Yet Divisive
As a series conclusion, We’ll Always Have Summer succeeds in providing closure while acknowledging that real life rarely offers neat resolutions. Some readers may find the ultimate romantic resolution frustrating, particularly those who invested heavily in the Belly-Jeremiah relationship. However, Han’s commitment to emotional truth over fan service demonstrates her integrity as a storyteller.
The epilogue, revealing Belly’s choice and its aftermath, provides the emotional satisfaction readers crave while maintaining the series’ themes about growth, forgiveness, and the complexity of human relationships.
Similar Reading Recommendations
Readers who enjoyed the Summer trilogy might appreciate:
- The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants series by Ann Brashares
- Eleanor & Park by Rainbow Rowell
- Anna and the French Kiss by Stephanie Perkins
- What’s Not to Love by Emily Wibberley
- Since You’ve Been Gone by Morgan Matson
Final Reflection
We’ll Always Have Summer serves as a worthy, if occasionally uneven, conclusion to Jenny Han’s coming-of-age trilogy. While it may not achieve the effortless charm of The Summer I Turned Pretty or the emotional devastation of It’s Not Summer Without You, it tackles the challenging task of bringing closure to a beloved series with honesty and emotional maturity. Han refuses to provide easy answers to complex questions about love, choice, and growing up, instead offering a conclusion that feels true to both her characters and the messy reality of young adulthood.
The novel succeeds in transforming what could have been a simple love triangle resolution into a meditation on the nature of love itself, making it essential reading for anyone who has followed Belly’s journey from the beginning. Despite its flaws, it stands as a testament to Han’s growth as a writer and her commitment to treating her readers’ emotional investment with the seriousness it deserves.