Laurie Gilmore returns to the beloved small town of Dream Harbor with The Gingerbread Bakery, the fifth installment in her internationally bestselling romance series. Following the success of The Pumpkin Spice Café, The Cinnamon Bun Book Store, The Christmas Tree Farm, and The Strawberry Patch Pancake House, Gilmore delivers another heartwarming tale that captures the essence of small-town romance during the most magical time of year.
Set against the backdrop of Jeanie and Logan’s long-awaited wedding, this enemies-to-lovers romance finally gives readers the story they’ve been demanding since the series began: Annie Andrews and Macaulay “Mac” Sullivan’s complicated love story.
The Heart of the Story: Annie and Mac’s Complex Dynamic
Annie Andrews embodies everything wonderful about Dream Harbor. She’s the town’s golden girl—friendly, civic-minded, and the proud owner of the beloved Gingerbread Bakery that has won “best window display” three Christmases running. But beneath her cheerful exterior lies a carefully guarded heart, one that’s been protecting itself from one particular person for over a decade.
Enter Mac Sullivan, the town’s reformed bad boy who’s returned to Dream Harbor after years of wandering. When he’s chosen as one of Logan’s groomsmen, Annie finds herself stuck with the one person she can’t stand—or rather, the one person she’s spent eleven years convincing herself she can’t stand.
Gilmore masterfully crafts their dynamic through alternating timelines that reveal the painful history between Annie and Mac. The “Then” chapters peel back layers of their teenage romance, showing us two young people who fell hard for each other during one magical Christmas season, only to have it all fall apart when Mac left town and never looked back. The “Now” chapters thrust them together for a wedding weekend where old wounds must be addressed and long-buried feelings can no longer be ignored.
Character Development: Where Growth Meets Authenticity
Annie’s character arc is particularly compelling. Gilmore presents her as someone who has built a successful life while carrying the weight of past hurt. Her initial hostility toward Mac feels genuine rather than manufactured drama—this is a woman who protected herself by channeling pain into anger, and watching her slowly let those defenses down is both heartbreaking and satisfying.
Mac, meanwhile, is given the more challenging task of proving himself worthy of redemption. His past mistakes aren’t glossed over or easily forgiven. Instead, Gilmore forces him to confront the reality of how his choices affected Annie, making his journey toward earning her trust feel earned rather than convenient.
The supporting cast of Dream Harbor residents continues to be one of the series’ greatest strengths. From the meddling book club ladies to the concerned townspeople worried about wedding details, each character feels lived-in and authentic. Their genuine investment in Annie and Mac’s relationship adds layers of community warmth that make Dream Harbor feel like a place readers want to visit themselves.
Writing Style: Gilmore’s Signature Blend of Sweet and Spice
Gilmore’s writing style has evolved beautifully throughout the Dream Harbor series, and The Gingerbread Bakery showcases her ability to balance light, cozy romance with deeper emotional themes. Her dialogue crackles with wit and authenticity, particularly in the banter between Annie and Mac. The sexual tension builds naturally without feeling forced, and when the emotional walls finally come down, the payoff feels genuinely earned.
The dual timeline structure works exceptionally well here, allowing readers to understand the weight of history between these characters while watching them navigate their present-day chemistry. Gilmore’s descriptions of winter in Dream Harbor are particularly evocative, making the town feel like a character in its own right.
However, some plot elements feel slightly predictable, particularly the wedding-weekend setup that forces our protagonists together. While the execution is charming, readers familiar with the romance genre will see certain developments coming from miles away.
Romance Elements: When Second Chances Feel Real
The enemies-to-lovers trope is expertly handled here, largely because Gilmore establishes legitimate reasons for Annie’s resentment. This isn’t surface-level antagonism—it’s rooted in real hurt and genuine character flaws that must be addressed. Mac’s redemption arc requires him to not just apologize, but to demonstrate real change and understanding of how his past actions affected Annie.
The forced proximity of the wedding weekend creates natural opportunities for tension and resolution, though some of the smaller conflicts feel manufactured to maintain the enemies dynamic. The romance builds at a believable pace, with physical attraction warring against emotional self-protection in ways that feel authentic to the characters’ ages and history.
Themes: Love, Forgiveness, and Small-Town Magic
At its core, The Gingerbread Bakery explores themes of forgiveness—both of others and ourselves. Annie must learn to forgive not just Mac, but also the teenage version of herself who fell so hard and got so hurt. Mac must prove that people can change while accepting responsibility for past mistakes.
The wedding setting reinforces themes of commitment and the courage required to open your heart again. Watching Jeanie and Logan’s happiness forces both Annie and Mac to confront what they might be missing by holding onto old hurts.
Dream Harbor itself represents the idea that sometimes the place you’re meant to be is the place you’ve been all along—a theme that resonates throughout the entire series.
Connection to the Broader Series
Longtime fans of the Dream Harbor series will appreciate the connections to previous books and characters. References to past couples and their journeys create a rich tapestry of interconnected stories, while setting up future installments. The mention of the upcoming The Daisy Chain Flower Shop has already generated excitement for what’s to come.
New readers can easily jump in here, as Gilmore provides enough context about previous characters without overwhelming newcomers with backstory. However, reading the series in order enhances the experience, particularly understanding the deep friendships between the core group.
Minor Criticisms: Room for Growth
While The Gingerbread Bakery succeeds in most areas, it’s not without minor flaws. The pacing occasionally lags in the middle section, and some secondary plot points feel underdeveloped. A few conflicts feel resolved a bit too easily, particularly considering the depth of hurt between the main characters.
Additionally, while Gilmore excels at creating cozy atmosphere, some readers might crave more conflict or higher stakes to maintain tension throughout the novel.
Perfect for Fans Of
Readers who enjoyed Emily Henry’s Beach Read, Christina Lauren’s The Unhoneymooners, or Jasmine Guillory’s The Wedding Date will find much to love here. The book also appeals to fans of Hallmark movies, small-town settings, and anyone who enjoys their romance with a healthy dose of community charm.
Similar Books to Add to Your TBR
- It Happened One Summer by Tessa Bailey
- The Spanish Love Deception by Elena Armas
- The Kiss Quotient by Helen Hoang
- The Flatshare by Beth O’Leary
- People We Meet on Vacation by Emily Henry
Final Verdict: A Worthy Addition to the Dream Harbor Collection
The Gingerbread Bakery delivers exactly what fans of the series expect: warmth, charm, and a satisfying romantic resolution wrapped in the cozy magic of Dream Harbor during the holidays. While it doesn’t break new ground in the romance genre, it executes familiar tropes with skill and heart.
Gilmore has created a world that feels like a warm hug on a cold day, populated with characters who feel like friends. Annie and Mac’s story provides the emotional depth and satisfying conclusion that readers have been waiting for since the series began.
For fans of the Dream Harbor series, this is essential reading. For newcomers to Gilmore’s work, it’s an excellent introduction to an author who understands how to blend comfort and romance in ways that leave readers planning their next visit to this charming fictional town.
The promise of The Daisy Chain Flower Shop coming in 2026 ensures that Dream Harbor’s magic will continue, making this series a reliable source of romance comfort reading for years to come.