The guide has a new body. He has horns, a barbed tail, folded bat wings and a face built to sell cologne, and he has been standing in his room in full formal dress for three hours waiting for two crawlers who are late because a television interview ran over. The moment the door closes behind them, he tears off the jacket and the tie in visible relief. It is a small comic beat, and it sets the terms of Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman: the performance is for the cameras, and the real work happens in this room, between the shows.
The Teacher Changes Jobs
Mordecai has always been the series’ best idea. A former crawler who never made it out, now bound to the dungeon as the guildmaster who prepares each new arrival, he knows the rules, the loopholes and the cost of both. In the first novel he lived behind a door that Carl and Donut could visit. Here the arrangement changes, and the change is engineered by the people he is trying to help.
During the race and class selection that opens the book, Donut picks a class that quietly attaches Mordecai to her as a manager. It means he must appear in every safe room the pair enters, with no codex, no television feed and no warning. The choice was planned in secret on the advice of the talk-show host Odette, and Carl has to let it look like the cat’s whim. Dinniman stages the moment as farce, with the guide swearing at a smug feline, but he lets the guilt sit afterwards. Carl knows he has deceived the one ally he trusts, and Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman keeps returning to the cost.
A Novel Shaped Like a Training Week
What follows gives Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman an unusual architecture. Most fantasy sequels move from battle to battle. This one moves from outing to debrief. Carl and Donut go into the ruins of the Over City, something terrible happens, and then they sit in a pub with Mordecai while he explains what they did wrong, what they missed and what the next mistake will cost. The nightly recap episode plays on the tavern screens; potions get mixed at the table; plans get rehearsed.
It works because the debriefs carry information the action cannot. Mordecai explains how the dungeon’s scripted characters are steered from outside, how the town’s residents are owned and memory-wiped, why most crawlers choose to stay human even when a better body is on offer. Carl, a planner by temperament, starts to build his own system in response: a set of named combat plays that both partners must follow without argument once one is called. The novel is, in effect, a training montage that keeps getting interrupted by catastrophe.
The rhythm has a price. When Mordecai gets interested in a subject, the plot waits. A late-night lecture on parasitic plants is fascinating for a page and indulgent by the fourth, and some of the class and race menus in the opening chapters read like a game manual with jokes in the margins.
The Coach Who Cannot Coach Himself
The finest thing in Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is how much of Mordecai stays hidden. He arrives at the first safe room so drunk that he vomits, sits in it and passes out, and the reader is invited to laugh. Then the details accumulate. Incubi, it turns out, cannot handle alcohol, so he brews a potion to cancel the weakness and dilutes it by eye. He was a student of fungi on his home world, which links naturally to mycology and to his enthusiasm for the vine monster Carl has to beat. He mentions, almost in passing, that Odette made him study a particular floor when the two of them reached it, and Carl and Donut exchange a look. A dealer in a nightclub greets him as an old customer from the early days.
None of this is explained, and Dinniman is wise to leave it that way. Mordecai’s anger at being made a manager is never fully accounted for, even when he admits the job pays better and may protect him. Late in the book he coaches the newcomer Katia through the painful work of sculpting her own face, a doppelganger’s chore he clearly understands from experience, and the patience in those pages says more about him than any backstory dump could.
What Carl’s Doomsday Scenario Teaches Without a Teacher
The other education in Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is Carl’s own. He disobeys his teacher constantly, takes the quests he is told to refuse, and gets results that are better and costlier than Mordecai predicted. The circus quest, which leaves Donut asleep under a curse with only Mongo on guard, is where the book proves it can do pathos as well as slapstick: a sudden memory of a childhood visit to a small-town circus with his mother, and of the saplings they planted afterwards, is the most affecting passage in the novel. Mongo, Donut’s pet raptor, grows from a squawking hatchling into a bodyguard, and the trio begins to feel like a household.
A few reservations need naming:
- The humour repeats, with the same catchphrases and outraged cries arriving on schedule.
- Crude jokes about bodily functions and Carl’s lack of trousers wear thin.
- Violence is graphic and sometimes played for laughs that do not land, including an injury to a child.
- Readers who dislike stat sheets will find long stretches of them.
Content warnings run to heavy gore, parasitic body horror, the murder of sex workers, heavy drinking and self-injury, with constant swearing but no sex on the page.
Where Carl’s Doomsday Scenario Falls in the Crawl
This is the second of eight novels so far, and it opens moments after the first ends, with no recap to speak of. Anyone new to the series should begin with Dungeon Crawler Carl; the jokes, the alliances and Mordecai’s whole situation depend on it. For readers already invested, Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman is the volume where the world opens up and the series becomes a long game rather than a gauntlet.
The Writer Behind Carl’s Doomsday Scenario
Dinniman earned his living for years drawing cats and travelling to cat shows, which explains a great deal about Princess Donut’s vanity and her grooming demands. When the pandemic shut those shows down in 2020, he turned the serial he had been writing into a full-time job, self-publishing the books as fast as he could finish them. Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman followed the first book by only a few months, and the author’s note at its end jokes about feeding his dog with the proceeds.
His bio describes a writer who also plays bass in a punk and metal band, and the books carry that energy. Much of the series’ audience arrived through the audiobooks, performed by Jeff Hays of Soundbooth Theater, whose voice for Donut has become as famous as the cat herself.
Where It Leaves You
Readers who like a mentor who is brilliant, damaged and funny will find a kindred spirit in Andy Weir’s Project Hail Mary, where knowledge is survival and friendship is learned under pressure. Dinniman’s own Operation Bounce House shows the same eye for a watching audience in a different war, and Terry Pratchett’s Guards! Guards! offers the comedy of competent people trapped in a ridiculous system. Carl’s Doomsday Scenario by Matt Dinniman ends with its students a little less dependent on their teacher, and with the strong suspicion that he cares about them far more than his contract requires.
