There’s something uniquely satisfying about stories that explore the complex dynamics between sisters. When you add a dead body, family secrets, and a camping trip gone terribly wrong, you get Drop Dead Sisters – a wickedly entertaining adult debut from YA author Amelia Diane Coombs that proves blood truly is thicker than water, especially when there’s a murder to cover up.
The Plot at a Glance
Twenty-nine-year-old Remi Finch has spent years avoiding her older sisters, Eliana and Maeve. When their hippie parents organize a camping trip to celebrate their 40th wedding anniversary, Remi reluctantly agrees to attend. But what starts as an awkward family reunion takes a dark turn when Guy Moran – a toxic figure from their past – shows up uninvited and ends up dead at their campsite. As the sisters scramble to deal with the situation, they uncover family secrets, confront past trauma, and discover that perhaps they’re more alike than they thought.
Writing Style & Narrative Voice
Coombs masterfully balances dark humor with genuine emotional depth. The story is told from Remi’s perspective, and her anxious, self-deprecating voice feels authentic and relatable. The author captures the millennial experience perfectly – from Remi’s dead-end job managing an online gaming community to her struggles with therapy and medication.
The pacing is brisk, with enough twists to keep readers guessing while never losing sight of the heart of the story: the complicated relationship between the three sisters. Coombs excels at writing dialogue that crackles with tension and humor, making even the darkest moments oddly entertaining.
Character Development
One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its well-developed characters:
- Remi: The youngest sister and our protagonist, struggling with anxiety and feeling like an outsider in her own family. Her growth throughout the story feels earned and authentic.
- Eliana: The perfectionist oldest sister whose carefully controlled life is unraveling due to divorce.
- Maeve: The free-spirited middle sister who maintains an carefully curated social media presence while keeping her real life private.
The supporting cast is equally compelling, from the well-meaning but chaotic hippie parents to the scene-stealing Aunt Lindy. Each character feels distinct and three-dimensional, contributing to the story’s rich tapestry of family dynamics.
Themes & Social Commentary
The novel explores several meaningful themes:
- Family loyalty and its limits
- The impact of childhood trauma
- Mental health and anxiety
- The performative nature of social media
- Female empowerment and solidarity
- The ways society often fails to protect women from predatory men
What Works Well
- The sister relationship feels genuine, with all its complexities and contradictions
- The mystery unfolds in unexpected ways that keep readers guessing
- The romantic subplot with Leo adds lightness without overshadowing the main story
- The dark humor lands consistently without making light of serious issues
- The camping setting creates both claustrophobia and opportunities for chaos
Room for Improvement
While Drop Dead Sisters is a strong debut in adult fiction, there are a few areas where it could be stronger:
- The resolution of the mystery relies heavily on coincidence
- Some side characters’ motivations could be better developed
- A few plot threads feel slightly rushed in the final act
- The ending might be too neat for some readers’ tastes
Comparison to Other Works
Fans of shows like Bad Sisters and Dead to Me will find much to love here, as will readers who enjoyed books like Dial A for Aunties by Jesse Q. Sutanto or The Family Plot by Megan Collins. The blend of family drama, dark comedy, and murder mystery puts it in good company with recent hits like Finlay Donovan Is Killing It by Elle Cosimano.
Impact and Relevance
What makes Drop Dead Sisters particularly relevant is its exploration of sisterhood in the modern age. Coombs captures the way family relationships have evolved in the era of social media and constant connectivity, while still maintaining distance. The book also tackles important issues like mental health and trauma recovery with sensitivity and nuance.
Final Verdict
Drop Dead Sisters is a compelling blend of murder mystery, family drama, and dark comedy that manages to be both entertaining and emotionally resonant. Despite some minor flaws, it’s a strong adult debut that showcases Coombs’ ability to craft complex characters and compelling relationships.
Who Should Read This Book
This book is perfect for:
- Readers who enjoy dark comedy with heart
- Mystery fans who appreciate family dynamics
- Anyone with siblings, especially sisters
- Fans of character-driven suspense
- Those who enjoy stories about dysfunctional families coming together
Previous Work and Future Potential
Coming from a successful career in YA fiction (including titles like Keep My Heart in San Francisco and Between You, Me, and the Honeybees), Coombs makes a confident transition to adult fiction. Her experience writing complex teenage characters translates well to exploring adult family dynamics and relationships.
Personal Reflection
What makes Drop Dead Sisters stand out is its ability to balance serious themes with genuine humor and heart. While the premise might sound dark, the execution is surprisingly uplifting. It’s a story about second chances, growing up (even when you’re already an adult), and learning that it’s never too late to rebuild relationships with family.
The book’s greatest achievement is making readers invest in the Finch sisters’ relationship while keeping them guessing about the mystery. By the end, you’re rooting for these imperfect, complicated women to figure things out—both the murder and their relationships with each other.
Conclusion
Drop Dead Sisters announces Amelia Diane Coombs as a fresh voice in adult fiction, combining sharp wit with emotional depth. While not perfect, it’s a highly entertaining read that will leave readers looking forward to what she writes next. The book proves that sometimes the best way to bring family together is through shared secrets—even if those secrets happen to involve a dead body.