B.K. Borison delivers her most enchanting work yet with Good Spirits, a paranormal romance that reimagines the classic Ghost of Christmas Past tale with warmth, wit, and undeniable heart. This isn’t your typical holiday romance filled with meet-cutes at Christmas markets—instead, Borison crafts a story where the supernatural meets the deeply personal, creating something genuinely magical.
The premise alone is irresistible: Nolan Callahan, a century-old Ghost of Christmas Past, finds himself assigned to haunt Harriet York, a woman who seems too genuinely kind to deserve supernatural intervention. What begins as a routine ghostly assignment transforms into an exploration of love that transcends the boundaries between life and death, past and present.
Character Development That Resonates Beyond the Grave
Harriet York: The People-Pleaser Who Finds Her Voice
Harriet emerges as Borison’s most relatable protagonist yet—a woman who has spent her life making herself smaller to fit into other people’s expectations. Her character arc from doormat to someone who discovers her own worth feels authentic and earned. Borison writes Harriet’s journey with remarkable sensitivity, never making her people-pleasing tendencies feel like character flaws to be fixed, but rather as survival mechanisms to be understood and gently released.
The beauty of Harriet’s character lies in her gradual awakening to her own value. Her relationship with her antique shop, inherited from her beloved Aunt Matilda, serves as a metaphor for her own hidden treasures waiting to be discovered. When she finally stands up to her cold, demanding mother at the winter gala, it’s a moment that feels both triumphant and heartbreaking.
Nolan Callahan: More Than Just Eye Candy with Supernatural Powers
Nolan could have easily fallen into the trap of being merely a brooding love interest with convenient ghostly abilities. Instead, Borison creates a character whose century of existence has left him feeling hollow and forgotten—until Harriet rekindles something he thought was lost forever. His Irish accent and old-world charm never feel forced or overwrought, and his genuine confusion about modern conveniences provides moments of levity without undermining his character’s depth.
The most compelling aspect of Nolan’s character is how his ghostly nature serves the story’s themes rather than just its plot. His inability to truly live, to taste food properly, or to have a future reflects the emotional numbness both characters have experienced. When he begins to feel more human around Harriet, it’s not just supernatural—it’s deeply symbolic.
Writing Style That Sparkles with Authenticity
Borison’s prose in Good Spirits represents a marked evolution in her writing style. Gone are some of the overly precious moments that occasionally marred her earlier works. Instead, she delivers dialogue that crackles with wit and banter that feels genuinely earned rather than forced. The chemistry between Harriet and Nolan builds gradually through small moments—shared cups of peppermint coffee, gentle teasing about button collections, and quiet conversations that reveal deeper truths.
The author’s handling of the magical elements deserves particular praise. The time-travel sequences to Harriet’s past never feel contrived or overly convenient. Instead, they serve to deepen our understanding of both characters while advancing the emotional stakes of their relationship. Borison resists the temptation to over-explain the supernatural mechanics, trusting readers to accept the magic as part of the story’s emotional truth.
Thematic Depth Beyond the Holiday Trappings
While Good Spirits is undeniably a Christmas romance, its themes extend far beyond seasonal sentiment. At its core, this is a story about finding worth in a world that has taught both characters they are forgettable. Harriet’s struggle with family expectations and Nolan’s century of feeling purposeless create parallel journeys toward self-acceptance and love.
The novel explores how past trauma can trap us in patterns of invisibility and self-denial. Both Harriet and Nolan have learned to make themselves smaller—she through people-pleasing, he through literal fading away. Their love story becomes a mutual rescue mission where they learn to see themselves through each other’s eyes.
Borison also weaves in subtle commentary about family dysfunction and the courage required to break generational patterns. Harriet’s relationship with her emotionally withholding parents serves as a stark contrast to the warmth she creates in her own spaces.
Technical Craftsmanship and Narrative Structure
The pacing of Good Spirits demonstrates Borison’s growing confidence as a storyteller. The novel never rushes toward its romantic climax, instead allowing the relationship to develop organically through shared experiences and growing intimacy. The supernatural elements are seamlessly integrated into the contemporary setting, creating a world that feels both magical and grounded.
The supporting cast, particularly Harriet’s best friend Sasha and the bureaucratic ghostly hierarchy, adds depth without cluttering the central romance. Each secondary character serves a purpose in advancing either plot or character development, never feeling extraneous.
Borison’s handling of the physical romance deserves mention for its tasteful heat and emotional resonance. The intimate scenes feel earned and advance the emotional arc rather than existing purely for titillation.
Areas for Critical Consideration
While Good Spirits succeeds admirably in most areas, it’s not without minor shortcomings. The resolution of Nolan’s ghostly status feels somewhat rushed, and readers might wish for more exploration of the supernatural bureaucracy that governs his existence. Additionally, some of Harriet’s family dynamics, while emotionally authentic, occasionally veer toward the melodramatic.
The novel’s length sometimes works against it, with certain sequences in the middle act feeling slightly padded. A tighter edit might have enhanced the overall impact, though the leisurely pacing does serve the romance well.
Comparative Context and Series Potential
Good Spirits represents a departure from Borison’s previous contemporary works while maintaining the cozy, small-town charm that defines her brand. Readers familiar with her Lovelight series will recognize the author’s gift for creating welcoming fictional spaces, but this novel’s supernatural elements add new dimensions to her storytelling toolkit.
The book succeeds where other paranormal romances sometimes fail by grounding its magical elements in genuine emotion. Unlike novels that use supernatural abilities as relationship shortcuts, Borison ensures that Nolan and Harriet’s connection transcends his ghostly nature.
Final Verdict: A Romance Worth Haunting For
Good Spirits stands as B.K. Borison’s most ambitious and successful work to date. It’s a romance that manages to be both deeply romantic and genuinely moving, with supernatural elements that enhance rather than overshadow the human story at its center. The novel proves that Christmas romance can be fresh and innovative while still delivering the emotional satisfaction readers crave.
This is a book that will linger with readers long after the final page, much like the best kind of haunting—gentle, persistent, and ultimately transformative. Borison has created characters who feel real enough to miss and a love story that proves some connections truly are timeless.
For readers seeking a romance that combines humor, heart, and just the right touch of magic, Good Spirits delivers everything one could wish for in a holiday read and more.
Recommended Similar Reads
If Good Spirits captures your heart, consider these similar romantic reads:
- The Ten Rules of Faking It by Sophie Sullivan – Contemporary romance with emotional depth
- Beach Read by Emily Henry – Enemies-to-lovers with genuine character growth
- The Spanish Love Deception by Elena Armas – Slow burn romance with witty banter
- The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid – Character-driven romance with secrets
- The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab – Paranormal romance exploring immortality and memory
For readers new to B.K. Borison’s work, her Lovelight Farms series offers similar cozy romance vibes in a contemporary small-town setting, while First-Time Caller showcases her talent for workplace romance with emotional depth.