In this delightful conclusion to The Wilmot Sisters series, Chloe Liese delivers a heartwarming romance that masterfully weaves together themes of self-discovery, healing, and the transformative power of love. Once Smitten, Twice Shy follows Juliet Wilmot and Will Orsino as they navigate their way from practice romance to real love, creating a story that is both tender and passionate.
Series Context
The Wilmot Sisters trilogy consists of three Shakespeare retellings:
- Two Wrongs Make a Right (Much Ado About Nothing)
- Better Hate than Never (The Taming of the Shrew)
- Once Smitten, Twice Shy (Twelfth Night)
Each book stands alone while interconnecting through the vibrant Wilmot sisters and their journey to love.
Strengths
Authentic Representation
Liese excels at portraying neurodivergent and chronically ill characters with depth and authenticity. Will’s autism and Juliet’s mixed connective tissue disease are seamlessly integrated into their characters rather than becoming their defining traits. The author’s own experiences inform these portrayals, lending them genuine credibility and emotional resonance.
Character Development
The protagonists’ growth feels organic and earned. Juliet’s journey from heartbreak to healing, and Will’s evolution from believing himself incapable of romantic love to embracing it fully, are beautifully rendered. Their individual character arcs complement each other while maintaining distinct identities.
Chemistry & Romance
The romantic tension between Will and Juliet sizzles from their first meeting. Their practice dates evolve naturally into genuine connection, making their eventual romance feel both inevitable and earned. The author excels at building emotional intimacy alongside physical attraction.
Room for Improvement
Pacing Issues
The middle section occasionally drags, particularly during the practice dating phase. Some scenes could have been condensed without losing their emotional impact.
Secondary Plot Resolution
While the main romance is satisfyingly concluded, some secondary storylines feel rushed or underdeveloped, particularly regarding the family dynamics and friend group interactions.
Predictability
Though well-executed, the plot follows fairly standard romance tropes. More surprising turns might have elevated the story further.
Themes & Analysis
Healing & Growth
The novel thoughtfully explores how past hurts shape our approach to love. Both protagonists must overcome their fears and limiting beliefs to embrace new possibilities.
Family & Community
The rich tapestry of family relationships and friendships adds depth to the central romance. The author effectively portrays how love exists within a broader network of connections.
Self-Acceptance
Will and Juliet’s journey involves accepting themselves as much as accepting each other. Their romance becomes a vehicle for personal growth and self-discovery.
Writing Style
Liese’s prose is warm and engaging, with moments of genuine humor balanced against deeper emotional resonance. Her dialogue feels natural, and her descriptive passages effectively create atmosphere without becoming purple prose.
Impact & Significance
Once Smitten, Twice Shy makes an important contribution to inclusive romance, featuring characters whose experiences are often marginalized or misrepresented in mainstream fiction. It demonstrates that everyone deserves a love story that celebrates their whole self.
Comparative Analysis
While similar to other Shakespeare retellings like Emily Henry’s Beach Read or Casey McQuiston’s Red, White & Royal Blue in its modern approach, Liese’s work stands out for its authentic representation and emotional depth.
Target Audience
This book will appeal to:
- Romance readers seeking authentic representation
- Fans of Shakespeare retellings
- Readers who enjoy slow-burn romance
- Those looking for stories about healing and second chances
Final Verdict
Once Smitten, Twice Shy is a touching conclusion to The Wilmot Sisters series that succeeds in both honoring its Shakespearean inspiration and creating something fresh and meaningful. Despite some pacing issues, the authentic representation, strong character development, and beautiful romance make it a worthy read.
Reader Advisory
Contains:
- Adult content
- Discussion of past emotional abuse
- References to chronic illness
- Mature themes and language
Recommendation
Highly recommended for romance readers seeking authentic representation and those who enjoy modern Shakespeare retellings with depth and heart. While it can be read as a standalone, reading the entire series will provide the richest experience.
The author has created a satisfying conclusion to the Wilmot Sisters series while opening up important conversations about neurodiversity and chronic illness in romance. Despite its minor flaws, Once Smitten, Twice Shy remains a touching and important addition to contemporary romance.