In Katherine Center’s latest offering, The Love Haters, we’re treated to a refreshing blend of romance, self-discovery, and adventure that goes well beyond the typical rom-com formula. Center has established herself as a master of what she calls “deep rom-coms”—stories that make you laugh while also tugging at your heartstrings—and this new novel firmly secures that reputation.
The story follows Katie Vaughn, a video producer whose life is in a holding pattern after a public breakup with her now-famous musician ex-fiancé. When faced with impending layoffs at work, Katie reluctantly accepts an assignment in Key West to profile Coast Guard rescue swimmer Tom “Hutch” Hutcheson. The catch? She can’t swim, a fairly significant problem given the nature of the job. As if that weren’t complicated enough, she learns that Hutch is the brother of her coworker Cole, who has his own complicated relationship with Hutch.
What follows is a delightful journey of self-discovery, unexpected romance, and literal sink-or-swim moments that transform Katie from someone who hates her body to someone who finally learns to appreciate it—and herself.
Strengths That Keep You Afloat
Center excels at creating characters who feel authentic. Katie’s struggles with body image are painfully relatable, from her “starvation diet” after internet trolls mocked her appearance to her phobia of wearing swimsuits. The way Center portrays Katie’s internal dialogue—the constant self-criticism and doubt—will resonate with many readers.
The supporting cast shines just as brightly. Hutch, with his stoic demeanor and melancholy eyes, is the perfect foil for Katie’s anxiety-ridden chattiness. Aunt Rue and “The Gals”—a group of vibrant older women living their best lives in Key West—bring warmth and wisdom to the story. Even George Bailey, Hutch’s traumatized Great Dane with thunder-phobia, becomes a fully realized character with his own emotional arc.
The Love Haters truly excels in its setting. Center brings Key West to life with vivid descriptions of colorful cottages, ocean breezes, and swaying palm trees. The contrast between Katie’s black-on-black wardrobe and the vibrant “chromophobia-curing” tropical fashions pushed on her by Aunt Rue creates a perfect visual metaphor for Katie’s emotional journey.
When the Story Treads Water
While the novel is largely engaging, it occasionally suffers from pacing issues. The middle section, where Katie and Hutch dance around their attraction while Cole’s lies complicate matters, sometimes feels drawn out. Some readers might find themselves wishing for the plot to move forward more quickly.
Additionally, the last-act hurricane rescue sequence, while thrilling, stretches credibility at times. The coincidence of Hutch being the exact rescue swimmer who finds Katie adrift at sea feels a bit too convenient, even for a romantic comedy.
The book also relies heavily on miscommunication as a plot device. While this is a staple of the genre, there are moments when a simple conversation could have resolved issues that instead drag on for chapters. This can occasionally feel frustrating, particularly when characters we’ve grown to care about are suffering unnecessarily.
Themes That Run Deep
What elevates The Love Haters beyond a simple beach read is Center’s thoughtful exploration of deeper themes:
- Self-acceptance and body positivity: Katie’s journey from hating her body to finally appreciating it forms the emotional core of the novel. Her realization that “I should have loved all of my everything. Because it was mine” is powerful and moving.
- Family wounds and healing: The fractured relationship between Hutch and Cole, stemming from childhood trauma, offers a compelling subplot about how we carry misunderstandings forward in life.
- Courage beyond physical bravery: While Hutch’s career as a rescue swimmer requires obvious physical courage, Katie’s willingness to face her fears—from wearing a swimsuit to learning to swim—demonstrates a different kind of bravery.
- Finding community: The found family of The Gals shows how friendship and connection can flourish at any stage of life.
Character Development Worth Celebrating
Katie’s transformation throughout the novel is masterfully handled. She begins as someone so consumed by self-hatred that she can barely look at herself in a mirror and evolves into a woman who can face a deadly hurricane and come out the other side with new appreciation for herself and her body.
What makes this journey compelling is how Center ties it to concrete actions and moments rather than abstract epiphanies. Katie’s gradual acceptance of colorful clothing, her growing comfort in swimwear, and ultimately her desperate moment of gratitude for her body when she believes she might die all contribute to a character arc that feels earned rather than imposed.
Hutch, too, experiences significant growth. His journey from stoic “love hater” to someone who can acknowledge his feelings demonstrates that even the most guarded hearts can open up when given the right reason.
Prose That Sparkles Like Sea Foam
Center’s writing style is conversational and accessible while maintaining emotional depth. Her use of first-person narration helps us experience Katie’s journey intimately, with internal monologues that feel genuine rather than contrived. The prose shines particularly in moments of humor. And in moments of emotional revelation.
The dialogue between characters crackles with energy, particularly the banter between Katie and Hutch. Their conversations feel organic, with the natural awkwardness and humor that characterize real-life attraction.
How It Compares to Center’s Other Works
Fans of Katherine Center’s previous novels like The Rom-Commers, The Bodyguard, Things You Save in a Fire, and How to Walk Away will find familiar elements in The Love Haters: a protagonist working through trauma, unexpected romance, and a journey toward self-acceptance. However, this novel leans more heavily into humor than some of her previous works, making it perhaps her most accessible “deep rom-com” yet.
The Key West setting also provides a fresh change from some of Center’s previous settings, allowing her to play with imagery and metaphors connected to the ocean and island life.
For Fans of Feel-Good Fiction
If you enjoy The Love Haters, you might also appreciate works by authors like:
- Emily Henry (Beach Read, People We Meet on Vacation, Great Big Beautiful Life)
- Christina Lauren (The Unhoneymooners, Love And Other Words)
- Jojo Moyes (Me Before You)
- Beth O’Leary (The Flatshare, Swept Away)
These authors similarly blend romance with deeper emotional journeys and character growth.
Final Verdict: Sink or Swim?
The Love Haters is a heartwarming, sometimes hilarious, and ultimately uplifting novel that delivers exactly what Center promises in her author’s note: “love stories are the best kind of therapy.” The book isn’t perfect—some plot conveniences and pacing issues keep it from absolute five-star territory—but the emotional journey is satisfying enough to make these flaws easy to forgive.
At its core, this is a story about learning to see yourself clearly and kindly, about finding the courage to be vulnerable, and about the healing power of connection. It’s about recognizing, as Katie does, that sometimes “letting yourself go” is exactly what you need to do.
For readers seeking a beach read with substance or a romantic comedy that doesn’t shy away from deeper emotional waters, The Love Haters offers a delightful escape that might just leave you looking at yourself differently when you close the final page.
The Love Haters reminds us that sometimes the most important love story isn’t about falling for someone else—it’s about falling for yourself.
Who Should Dive In?
- Readers who enjoy rom-coms with emotional depth
- Anyone who has struggled with body image issues
- Fans of stories featuring found family
- Those who appreciate coastal settings
- People who believe in second chances—for others and themselves
Who Might Want to Stay on Shore?
- Readers who prefer strictly realistic fiction (some plot coincidences require suspension of disbelief)
- Those looking for steamy romance (this is more sweet than spicy)
- Fans of fast-paced thrillers (the middle section moves at a leisurely pace)
Katherine Center has once again crafted a story that entertains while it heals, offering readers a reminder that love—of self and others—might be worth all the trouble after all.