Lisa Harding’s The Wildelings is a slow-burn literary thriller wrapped in the ornate shadows of Dark Academia. With its vivid character studies, morally ambivalent relationships, and deep psychological layering, the novel navigates the intersection of friendship, philosophy, and formative trauma. A novel as beautiful as it is unsettling, The Wildelings reveals how easily love, loyalty, and intellect can become weapons when wielded by the wrong hands.
In the lineage of Lisa Harding’s earlier works—Harvesting (2014), a haunting tale of sex trafficking, and Bright Burning Things (2021), an intimate portrayal of addiction and motherhood—The Wildelings is her most cerebral novel yet. Here, she trades physical entrapment for psychological confinement, placing her characters in the rarefied air of Wilde, a fictional elite university where intellect is currency and identity is constantly under negotiation.
Storyline Overview: From Devotion to Dissonance
The story begins with Jessica and Linda, inseparable childhood best friends, starting anew at Wilde University in Dublin. Both girls come from fractured family backgrounds and have long relied on their symbiotic relationship to survive. Jessica is the bold, creative, and self-assured one; Linda is quieter, gentler, and more grounded. Their connection, however, begins to unravel when Mark, a charismatic older philosophy student, enters their lives.
Mark is magnetic—enigmatic, intense, and full of intoxicating ideas about art, freedom, and truth. When Linda begins dating him, she transforms—subtly, then alarmingly. Jessica, increasingly isolated, begins to question everything: her friendship, her agency, her sanity. And as Mark’s influence deepens, drawing in other members of their social circle, the group veers into psychological and emotional territory none of them are prepared for.
The fallout is devastating. Guilt, betrayal, and loss ripple through the narrative, culminating in a tragic rupture that will define Jessica’s adulthood. The novel moves fluidly between past and present, with Jessica’s voice—older, emotionally distant, in therapy—anchoring the haunting story of what happened at Wilde.
Major Themes: The Fragility of Becoming
Harding explores core psychological and philosophical themes with intensity and nuance:
- Female friendship and co-dependency: Jessica and Linda’s bond is as passionate and complicated as any romantic relationship. It thrives on mutual need but deteriorates under the weight of secrecy and silence.
- The danger of charisma: Mark is a chilling study in intellectual manipulation. He doesn’t seduce with force, but with language, theory, and ideology—cloaking control in the guise of enlightenment.
- Identity and transformation: Wilde is not just a university; it’s a crucible. Every character arrives hoping to become someone else. What unfolds instead is the disintegration of identity under pressure.
- Truth, performance, and morality: Through references to Shakespeare, Greek tragedy, and theatrical performance, Harding explores how we perform versions of ourselves—for approval, for love, for survival.
Jessica, Linda, and Mark: A Study in Influence
Jessica
Jessica is the narrative center—a brilliant but damaged young woman searching for meaning and stability. Harding writes her with a breathtaking intensity. Jessica is reflective, poetic, and prickly; her sharp mind and wit contrast with her inner fragility. Through her eyes, we witness not just the events at Wilde, but the emotional erosion that follows.
Her narration is filled with self-questioning and philosophical inquiry. She is both observer and participant, often unreliable in memory but authentic in pain. As an adult, Jessica lives in a state of emotional detachment—a protective shell forged from the traumas of her past.
Linda
Linda’s character arc is quiet but profound. She begins as Jessica’s emotional ballast but is soon swept into Mark’s orbit. Her need for connection and meaning makes her vulnerable, but Harding never strips her of agency. Linda’s choices may be misguided, but they are deeply human. Her evolution—from best friend to something unreachable—is one of the novel’s most heartbreaking threads.
Mark
Mark is the embodiment of seductive intellect gone toxic. A philosophy student and aspiring playwright, he espouses radical ideas about authenticity, self-discovery, and rebellion. Beneath his intellectual veneer lies a manipulative streak. He isolates Linda from Jessica, undermines their trust, and exerts subtle but totalizing control. Mark is not a villain in the traditional sense—there’s no violence, no overt malice—but his ability to dismantle the emotional foundations of those around him is terrifying.
Literary Style and Narrative Voice
Harding’s prose is lyrical, fragmented, and emotionally alive. The novel is infused with theatricality—both literal (drama rehearsals, performances) and psychological. Her sentences often shimmer with poetic rhythm, reflecting Jessica’s inner monologue: urgent, cerebral, haunted.
The structure itself mirrors trauma. The novel is episodic, layered with time jumps, italicized memory fragments, and therapeutic sessions. The story unfolds like a memory being pieced together in therapy—nonlinear, recursive, always shadowed by what cannot be fully spoken.
Harding doesn’t just write scenes—she composes emotional landscapes. Her attention to sensory detail—the chill of Dublin air, the echo of footsteps on polished wood, the brush of a costume’s silk—is immersive and deliberate.
Literary and Philosophical References
Harding weaves literary references into the novel’s fabric with elegance. Shakespeare is especially central: Jessica, named after the runaway daughter from The Merchant of Venice, becomes a symbol of rebellion and displacement. The characters discuss texts by Sartre, Camus, and Beckett—not just as name-drops, but as thematic anchors for the questions the novel poses:
- What does it mean to be free?
- Is authenticity real, or just another performance?
- Can love exist without control?
These allusions enhance the novel’s depth without alienating readers unfamiliar with philosophy or literature. Harding uses them not to show off, but to enrich the psychological and existential stakes of her characters’ journeys.
Strengths: A Masterclass in Atmosphere and Emotional Truth
- Complex characters: No one is wholly innocent or evil. Jessica is flawed and often self-absorbed; Linda is both victim and enabler; Mark is charming yet chilling. Their dynamic is both compelling and deeply uncomfortable.
- Tonal mastery: The novel moves seamlessly between the cerebral and the visceral. It can feel like a dream—seductive and slow—but the emotional impact is raw and real.
- Dark Academia aesthetics: Readers drawn to moody libraries, whispered confidences, and candlelit rehearsals will be swept away by the Wilde setting. But unlike other Dark Academia novels that romanticize elitism, The Wildelings by Lisa Harding critiques it. Harding uses the aesthetic to expose emotional and moral corrosion, not just indulge in it.
- Subtle suspense: This isn’t a thriller in the conventional sense, but tension builds methodically. The unease creeps in early and never lets go.
Limitations: Where the Story Falters
While The Wildelings by Lisa Harding is a triumph in tone and theme, it has moments of narrative stagnation:
- Pacing: The novel’s middle section can feel drawn out, especially during Mark’s philosophical dialogues. While thematically relevant, these exchanges occasionally slow the momentum.
- Limited exploration of supporting characters: Figures like Jacques and Jonathan are intriguing but underdeveloped. Their potential to deepen the social dynamics of the friend group is left largely untapped.
- Ambiguity in resolution: The final chapters offer emotional resolution, but some readers may find the ending too restrained. There is catharsis, yes—but not closure.
That said, these are minor issues in an otherwise emotionally and intellectually resonant novel.
Comparative Titles and Readership
If you appreciated:
- The Secret History by Donna Tartt
- Bunny by Mona Awad
- If We Were Villains by M.L. Rio
- Acts of Desperation by Megan Nolan
- Exciting Times by Naoise Dolan
You will find The Wildelings by Lisa Harding a worthy, perhaps even superior, addition to your shelf.
Lisa Harding distinguishes herself in this space by writing female characters with unparalleled depth. Her narratives do not offer easy morality or redemption—but they offer truth, even if it’s painful.
Final Thoughts: A Tender, Cerebral Tragedy
The Wildelings by Lisa Harding is not a book that screams—it whispers, coaxes, and haunts. Lisa Harding has crafted an unsettling tale of transformation where love can consume, ideas can destroy, and silence can be just as violent as words. This novel is less about what happens, and more about how it feels when everything you believed in—friendship, intellect, even yourself—begins to dissolve.
It’s a story for readers who relish slow-burn narratives, psychological complexity, and literary nuance. Harding has proven, once again, that the most dangerous terrain we navigate is not the external world, but the interior lives we share—and the parts we keep hidden.