Well Actually by Mazey Eddings - Book Review by Book CLB

Mazey Eddings serves up her most biting and brilliant work yet in “Well, Actually,” a contemporary romance that transforms what could have been a simple enemies-to-lovers story into a razor-sharp dissection of toxic masculinity, workplace harassment, and the complexities of modern femininity. While the book delivers the swoony romance readers expect from Eddings, it’s the unflinching social commentary that elevates this from fluffy beach read to essential contemporary fiction.

Plot That Packs a Punch

The Setup: When Your Past Goes Viral

Eva Kitt never imagined her career would revolve around eating hot dogs with D-list celebrities on a show called “Sausage Talk,” but here she is, twenty-seven and drowning in mediocrity. When a tipsy Friday night leads to a viral video calling out her college ex—social media darling Rylie Cooper—for being terrible in bed and generally awful, Eva’s life takes a dramatic turn.

What makes this premise brilliant is how Eddings uses Eva’s viral moment as a catalyst for examining how women’s anger gets weaponized, commodified, and ultimately dismissed. The setup isn’t just about embarrassment—it’s about power dynamics, career desperation, and the ways women are forced to perform their own humiliation for content.

The Fake Dating Twist That Actually Works

Unlike many romance novels where fake dating feels contrived, Eddings crafts a scenario that feels both organic and thematically relevant. When Eva’s bosses force her to interview Rylie on her show, he proposes a deal: let him take her on a series of dates to prove he’s changed, documenting their “redemption arc” for his podcast about deconstructing toxic masculinity.

The genius of this setup is how it mirrors real-world influencer culture while examining the performative nature of personal growth. Are we watching genuine change or just better marketing? Eddings keeps readers guessing while delivering genuinely swoon-worthy moments.

Character Development: Flawed and Fabulous

Eva Kitt: The Angry Young Woman We Need

Eva Kitt is a masterclass in writing unlikable female protagonists who remain utterly compelling. Sarcastic, bitter, and professionally stagnant, Eva could easily become insufferable. Instead, Eddings imbues her with such authentic vulnerability and razor-sharp wit that readers can’t help but root for her.

Eva’s character arc brilliantly explores how women’s anger—especially justified anger—gets pathologized and dismissed. Her caustic exterior masks deep wounds about self-worth, career disappointment, and romantic betrayal. Eddings doesn’t ask readers to excuse Eva’s sometimes cruel behavior, but she provides context that makes her complexity fascinating rather than frustrating.

The way Eva processes trauma through humor and aggression feels authentic rather than performative. Her journey from cynical host of a ridiculous show to investigative journalist exposing workplace harassment is both personally satisfying and socially significant.

Rylie Cooper: Redemption Done Right

Crafting a genuinely reformed “toxic masculinity educator” who doesn’t feel like a complete fraud is no small feat, but Eddings manages it beautifully. Rylie’s past behavior—being homophobic, selfish, and emotionally manipulative in college—isn’t glossed over or excused. Instead, Eddings shows the hard work of genuine growth.

What sets Rylie apart from other “reformed bad boy” love interests is the specificity of his evolution. His podcast isn’t just a career move—it’s genuine penance. His attraction to Eva isn’t based on wanting to “fix” her or prove himself, but on recognizing her intelligence, humor, and strength. The way he supports her career ambitions and validates her anger feels revolutionary in the romance landscape.

Writing Style: Eddings at Her Finest

Voice and Tone

Eddings has always excelled at crafting distinctive character voices, but Eva Kitt might be her most successful creation. The first-person narration crackles with sardonic energy while maintaining enough vulnerability to keep readers invested. Lines like “I’ve worked hard over the years to train my algorithms not to show me this asshole despite his prevalence and ever-growing fanbase, but the universe is a messy bitch that loves disrupting my peace of mind” perfectly capture Eva’s voice—bitter, funny, and oddly endearing.

The prose style adapts beautifully to match Eva’s personality. Short, punchy sentences during moments of anger give way to longer, more lyrical passages during vulnerable scenes. Eddings has mastered the art of making readers feel like they’re inside Eva’s head rather than simply observing her story.

Dialogue That Sparkles

The banter between Eva and Rylie is electric, moving seamlessly between antagonistic sparring and genuine intimacy. Their conversations during the podcast recordings are particularly well-crafted, showing how performance can gradually become authenticity. The supporting characters—especially Eva’s friend Aida—feel like real people with their own agendas rather than convenient plot devices.

Themes: More Than Just Romance

Toxic Masculinity and Performative Feminism

“Well, Actually” by Mazey Eddings tackles weighty themes without becoming preachy. The exploration of toxic masculinity goes beyond surface-level “men are trash” messaging to examine how these behaviors develop, how they harm everyone involved, and what genuine accountability looks like. Rylie’s podcast serves as both plot device and thematic exploration, showing how men can do the work of unlearning harmful behaviors.

Equally important is the book’s examination of how women navigate professional spaces. Eva’s treatment at Soundbites Media—from being forced to eat hot dogs for content to enduring sexual harassment from her boss—reflects real workplace experiences with uncomfortable accuracy.

Career Ambition and Creative Fulfillment

The book’s treatment of career ambition feels particularly relevant for millennial and Gen Z readers. Eva’s struggle with being trapped in unfulfilling work while drowning in student debt, watching friends succeed while she stagnates, captures a specific generational anxiety. Her journey from “Sausage Talk” host to investigative journalist isn’t just character development—it’s a fantasy of meaningful work triumphing over corporate exploitation.

The Performance of Public Life

Eddings brilliantly explores how social media has commodified authenticity. Eva’s viral video, Rylie’s carefully curated content, and the corporate demands for “engagement” all reflect how genuine emotion becomes content and personal growth becomes brand management. The book questions whether it’s possible to have authentic relationships in an increasingly performative world.

Romance Elements: Chemistry and Growth

The Enemies-to-Lovers Evolution

The romantic development between Eva and Rylie feels both inevitable and surprising. Their initial antagonism stems from genuine hurt and incompatibility rather than manufactured conflict. Watching them rediscover each other—and discover who they’ve become—provides genuine emotional payoff.

The sexual tension is expertly built through their verbal sparring and gradually deepening emotional intimacy. When they finally come together, it feels earned rather than rushed. Eddings excels at showing how good romantic chemistry requires both physical attraction and intellectual respect.

Supporting the Relationship Arc

The romance succeeds because both characters have compelling individual arcs that enhance rather than overshadow their relationship. Eva’s journey toward professional fulfillment and Rylie’s commitment to genuine accountability create a foundation for a partnership between equals rather than a rescue fantasy.

Social Commentary: Sharp and Necessary

Workplace Harassment and Power Dynamics

The subplot involving Eva’s toxic workplace environment—particularly William’s harassment and Landry’s complicity—provides crucial context for understanding Eva’s anger and desperation. Eddings doesn’t shy away from showing how workplace harassment affects women’s career trajectories and mental health.

Eva’s eventual decision to expose the harassment through investigative journalism transforms her from victim to advocate, providing both personal catharsis and social relevance. The way her story gains traction reflects real-world movements toward accountability in media and entertainment industries.

Internet Culture and Viral Fame

The book’s exploration of viral culture—how quickly public opinion can shift, how personal stories become commodified content, and how social media outrage often lacks lasting impact—feels remarkably current. Eva’s experience going viral captures both the exhilaration and horror of sudden internet fame.

Areas for Improvement

Pacing in the Middle Act

While the beginning and ending of “Well, Actually” by Mazey Eddings are exceptionally strong, the middle section occasionally feels rushed. The transition from antagonism to genuine attraction could have been developed more gradually, allowing readers to better understand the shift in Eva’s feelings.

Secondary Character Development

While Aida serves her purpose as Eva’s supportive friend, she occasionally feels more like a plot device than a fully realized character. Additional development of the supporting cast would have enriched the world-building and provided more opportunities for character growth.

Resolution of Professional Conflicts

While Eva’s exposé of Soundbites provides satisfying emotional resolution, the practical aftermath—career consequences, legal ramifications, and industry changes—could have been explored more thoroughly. The ending feels slightly too neat given the complexity of the issues raised.

Comparison to Eddings’ Previous Works

Evolution as a Writer

“Well, Actually” represents significant growth in Mazey Eddings’ storytelling abilities. While previous works like “Lizzie Blake’s Best Mistake” and “A Brush with Love” excelled at character development and emotional authenticity, this book adds layers of social commentary and thematic depth without sacrificing the heart that makes her work so appealing.

The writing is more confident, the themes more ambitious, and the character work more nuanced than in her earlier novels. Eva Kitt joins the ranks of Eddings’ most memorable protagonists while representing a new level of complexity in her characterization.

Consistent Strengths

Eddings maintains her signature strengths: authentic character voices, excellent dialogue, and the ability to balance humor with genuine emotional depth. Her commitment to representing neurodivergent characters and addressing mental health continues to set her apart in the romance genre.

Final Verdict: A Romance That Demands Attention

“Well, Actually” by Mazey Eddings succeeds on multiple levels—as a satisfying romance, a sharp social commentary, and a character study of a woman finding her voice in an industry designed to silence her. Eddings has crafted something special: a book that entertains while challenging readers to examine their own assumptions about masculinity, femininity, and power.

While not without minor flaws in pacing and secondary character development, the novel’s strengths far outweigh its weaknesses. Eva Kitt’s journey from bitter podcast host to confident investigative journalist provides both personal satisfaction and broader social relevance.

This is Eddings at her most ambitious and successful, creating a romance that feels both deeply personal and socially significant. “Well, Actually” by Mazey Eddings proves that contemporary romance can tackle serious themes without losing its heart—or its heat.

UrbanObserver

Subscribe to newsletter

Fiction

Non-Fiction

Poetry

Book List

Reader's Corner

Author Interview

Writing Guide

Publishing Guide

Book Marketing Guide

The Book CLB