Megan Collins’ latest psychological thriller, Cross My Heart, presents an intriguing premise: what happens when a heart transplant recipient becomes romantically obsessed with her donor’s widower? The novel skillfully blends elements of contemporary romance with dark psychological suspense, creating a narrative that keeps readers guessing while exploring deeper themes of identity and self-worth.
Plot Analysis
The story follows Rosie Lachlan, a heart transplant recipient working in her parents’ bridal salon, who becomes convinced that her new heart belonged to Daphne Thorne, wife of bestselling author Morgan Thorne. Through an anonymous donor communication service, Rosie initiates contact with Morgan, harboring the secret belief that they’re destined to be together. However, as she delves deeper into Morgan’s past and his relationship with Daphne, she uncovers troubling questions about his possible involvement in his wife’s death.
Narrative Structure and Pacing
Collins employs a compelling structure that alternates between:
- Present-day events
- DonorConnect messages between Rosie and Morgan
- Flashbacks to Rosie’s previous relationships
- Excerpts from Daphne’s poetry
The pacing is particularly strong in the first half, building tension through Rosie’s growing obsession with Morgan and the gradual revelation of unsettling details about his past. The second half accelerates into more traditional thriller territory, though some readers might find the shift in tone somewhat abrupt.
Character Development
Rosie Lachlan
The protagonist is expertly crafted as a complex, flawed character whose actions often make readers uncomfortable while remaining psychologically believable. Her history of romantic fixation and tendency to see relationships through “Rosie-colored glasses” is well-developed and provides crucial context for her current obsession.
Morgan Thorne
Collins creates an effectively ambiguous character in Morgan, keeping readers guessing about his true nature until the final chapters. His characterization through both direct interaction and second-hand accounts adds layers to the mystery.
Supporting Characters
- Nina (Rosie’s best friend) serves as both conscience and foil
- Blair (Morgan’s best friend) is particularly well-drawn
- Edith provides an interesting parallel to Rosie’s obsessive tendencies
Thematic Depth
The novel explores several interconnected themes:
- The nature of identity and how it relates to physical bodies
- The fine line between love and obsession
- The reliability of perception versus reality
- The impact of trauma on relationship patterns
- The role of social media in modern romance
Writing Style and Prose
Collins’ prose is sharp and engaging, particularly in passages describing Rosie’s internal struggles. The author has a talent for capturing the uncomfortable space between rational thought and obsessive behavior. However, some metaphors involving hearts and love occasionally feel heavy-handed.
Strengths
- Innovative premise that puts a fresh spin on the psychological thriller genre
- Well-researched medical details regarding heart transplants
- Nuanced exploration of romantic obsession
- Strong character development
- Effective use of unreliable narration
Areas for Improvement
- Some plot twists feel telegraphed too early
- The final act relies heavily on coincidence
- Certain supporting characters could be more fully developed
- The resolution might feel too neat for some readers
- Some symbolic elements are overworked
Comparison to Previous Works
Fans of Collins’ previous novels (The Family Plot, Behind the Red Door) will recognize her skill at crafting complex female protagonists and exploring the darker aspects of relationships. However, Cross My Heart represents a more ambitious attempt to blend psychological insight with thriller elements.
Genre Context
The novel sits comfortably within the psychological thriller genre while incorporating elements of:
- Medical drama
- Romance
- Literary fiction
- Mystery
Impact and Resonance
Cross My Heart succeeds in making readers question their own perceptions of love and obsession. Collins forces us to examine the stories we tell ourselves about relationships and the lengths we might go to find connection.
Technical Elements
The author’s research into heart transplants and donor communication adds authenticity to the narrative. The depiction of social media stalking and online investigation feels particularly timely and realistic.
Similar Works
Readers who enjoy this novel might also appreciate:
- You by Caroline Kepnes
- The Kind Worth Killing by Peter Swanson
- The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides
Final Assessment
Cross My Heart is an engaging psychological thriller that occasionally suffers from predictability but compensates with strong character work and thematic depth. While the ending might not surprise genre veterans, the journey there is compelling enough to maintain interest.
Recommended for:
- Fans of psychological thrillers with romantic elements
- Readers interested in exploring themes of obsession and identity
- Those who enjoy unreliable narrators
- Fans of contemporary suspense with medical elements
May not appeal to:
- Readers seeking traditional romance
- Those who prefer action-driven thrillers
- Readers sensitive to themes of stalking and obsession
Conclusion
Despite its flaws, Cross My Heart represents a solid addition to the psychological thriller genre. Collins’ ability to maintain tension while exploring complex psychological themes makes for an engaging read, even when some plot elements feel familiar. The novel’s strength lies not in its surprises but in its careful examination of obsession, identity, and the stories we tell ourselves about love.
The book serves as a reminder that sometimes the most dangerous deceptions are the ones we create ourselves, and that true self-worth can’t be found in another person’s love – even if that person’s heart beats inside your chest.