Holmes Is Missing marks the second installment in Patterson and Sitts’ innovative Holmes, Marple & Poe series, following their successful debut “Holmes, Marple & Poe.” This contemporary mystery thriller cleverly reimagines three legendary detective names in a fresh, urban setting while delivering an intricate kidnapping plot that keeps readers guessing until the end.
The Story at a Glance
In modern-day Brooklyn, the elite detective agency Holmes, Marple & Poe has gained quick success through their unique combination of skills. When six infants mysteriously disappear from St. Michael’s Hospital’s maternity ward, Auguste Poe (the muscle) and Margaret Marple (the keen observer) must solve the case without their brilliant partner Brendan Holmes, who is conspicuously absent at a rehab facility battling his own demons.
Character Development & Dynamics
The authors excel at crafting distinct personalities for their protagonists. Auguste Poe brings raw intensity and action-hero qualities while harboring deep emotional wounds. Margaret Marple combines British sophistication with sharp investigative instincts. Their evolving relationship provides an engaging subplot that adds depth to the procedural elements.
The supporting cast is equally well-drawn, particularly Detective Lieutenant Helene Grey, whose pregnancy revelation adds personal stakes to the investigation. Captain Graham Duff serves as an effective antagonist within law enforcement, while the mysterious Oliver Paul emerges as a fascinating villain with complex motivations.
Plot Structure & Pacing
Patterson and Sitts maintain their signature fast-paced style with short chapters and multiple plotlines that converge masterfully. The narrative alternates between the infant kidnapping investigation, Holmes’ personal journey, and the emerging “Mother Murders” cold case. While this juggling act occasionally feels rushed, it successfully keeps readers engaged throughout.
Strengths & Notable Elements
- Strong character development and interpersonal dynamics
- Clever integration of classic detective fiction elements in a modern setting
- Well-researched technical details about police procedure and investigation methods
- Effective balance of action, procedure, and emotional depth
- Compelling romantic subplots that enhance rather than distract from the main mystery
Areas for Improvement
- Some plot resolutions feel rushed or convenient
- The connection between various criminal enterprises could be better explained
- Certain character motivations, particularly for the villains, could use more depth
- The international aspect of the case feels somewhat underdeveloped
Writing Style & Technical Elements
The authors maintain Patterson’s trademark accessible prose while adding sophisticated elements that pay homage to the classic detective fiction that inspired their characters. The dialogue is sharp and often witty, though occasionally veering into cliché territory.
Series Context & Growth
Building on the foundation established in the first book, this sequel expands the universe while deepening the main characters’ backstories. The authors successfully avoid the common pitfall of sequel redundancy by introducing fresh challenges and evolving relationships.
Impact & Relevance
The novel tackles contemporary issues like human trafficking and addiction while maintaining its entertainment value. The authors handle sensitive topics with appropriate gravity while avoiding excessive darkness.
Comparative Analysis
While not reaching the cerebral heights of Conan Doyle or Christie’s original works, this modern interpretation successfully captures their spirit while creating something new. The series compares favorably to other contemporary detective fiction like Michael Connelly’s Bosch series or Tana French’s Dublin Murder Squad books.
Final Verdict
Despite some minor flaws, “Holmes Is Missing” delivers an engaging mystery that will satisfy both fans of classic detective fiction and modern thriller readers. The novel successfully builds on its predecessor while setting up intriguing possibilities for future installments.
Recommendation
Recommended for:
- Fans of contemporary detective fiction
- Readers who enjoy classic mystery elements in modern settings
- Those who appreciate complex character relationships alongside procedural elements
- Patterson fans looking for something slightly more sophisticated than his typical fare
About the Authors
James Patterson needs little introduction as one of the world’s bestselling authors. Brian Sitts brings fresh energy to their collaboration, particularly evident in the technical aspects of the investigation and the nuanced character development.
Looking Forward
The ending leaves several threads intentionally unresolved, setting up promising possibilities for future installments while providing satisfactory closure to the main plot lines. Readers will likely anticipate the next chapter in this innovative series.
Holmes Is Missing proves that there’s still room for fresh interpretation of classic detective fiction tropes when handled with skill and respect for the source material. While not perfect, it’s a worthy addition to the modern mystery landscape and a solid continuation of this promising series.