In her sophomore novel, Perfect Fit, Clare Gilmore delivers a charming and insightful exploration of love, ambition, and self-discovery. Perfect Fit follows Josephine Davis, a driven young CEO navigating the complexities of running a fashion brand while unexpectedly reconnecting with Will Grant, her former best friend’s twin brother. The novel masterfully weaves together themes of burnout, personal growth, and the delicate balance between professional success and emotional fulfillment.
Character Development & Dynamics
Josephine Davis
Gilmore crafts a remarkably authentic protagonist in Josie. Far from the typical “girlboss” trope, Josie embodies the real struggles of young female entrepreneurs. Her journey from compulsive overachiever to someone learning to prioritize personal happiness feels genuine and relatable. The author skillfully portrays Josie’s anxiety about social media and public perception without making it feel contrived.
Will Grant
Will’s character arc is equally compelling. His transformation from a moody teenager to a thoughtful, supportive partner showcases Gilmore’s talent for character evolution. His passion for cooking and desire to change careers adds depth to what could have been a standard romantic lead. The vulnerability he displays, particularly regarding his father’s infidelity and its impact on his family, makes him a fully realized character.
Writing Style & Narrative Structure
Gilmore’s writing shines brightest in dialogue and internal monologue. The banter between characters feels natural and often humorous, while the emotional moments land with impact. The alternating timelines between past and present are well-handled, though occasionally the transitions could be smoother.
Strengths:
- Rich, multifaceted characters
- Authentic representation of workplace dynamics
- Well-paced romantic development
- Strong female friendships
- Realistic portrayal of anxiety and burnout
Areas for Improvement:
- Some plot points feel rushed in the final third
- Secondary character arcs could be more developed
- The B Corp certification subplot occasionally overshadows the main narrative
- Certain conflicts resolve too neatly
Themes & Social Commentary
Work-Life Balance
The novel excels in its examination of burnout culture and the pressure to maintain a perfect image. Josie’s struggle with her workaholic tendencies resonates strongly in today’s hustle culture climate.
Female Friendship
The relationship between Josie and Camila stands out as one of the book’s strongest elements. Their friendship feels authentic and nuanced, avoiding common stereotypes about female competition in the workplace.
Romance Development
The slow-burn romance between Josie and Will is wonderfully crafted. Their shared history adds complexity to their developing relationship, while their present-day chemistry feels electric and earned. The author takes time to build their connection through meaningful conversations and shared experiences.
Technical Elements
Pacing
The story maintains a steady rhythm throughout most of the narrative, though it occasionally loses momentum during detailed business discussions. The third act feels slightly rushed compared to the careful buildup of the first two-thirds.
World-Building
Gilmore’s Austin comes alive through vivid descriptions and local color. The fashion industry setting feels well-researched and authentic, adding depth to the story without overwhelming readers with technical details.
Cultural Impact & Relevance
The novel tackles timely themes including:
- Social media anxiety
- Corporate responsibility
- Mental health awareness
- Career transitions
- Modern dating dynamics
Comparison to Similar Works
While Perfect Fit shares DNA with contemporary romance authors like Emily Henry and Ali Hazelwood, Clare Gilmore carves out her own niche with her focus on entrepreneurship and authentic portrayal of business dynamics.
Final Verdict
Perfect Fit is a strong sophomore effort that demonstrates Clare Gilmore’s growth as an author since her debut. While not without its flaws, the novel successfully combines romance with relevant social commentary and character-driven storytelling.
Recommended For:
- Fans of contemporary romance with substance
- Readers interested in workplace dynamics
- Those who enjoy slow-burn romance
- Anyone dealing with career burnout or transition
Not Recommended For:
- Readers seeking primarily light-hearted romance
- Those triggered by discussions of anxiety
- People looking for traditional business fiction
Impact and Lasting Impression
Perfect Fit by Clare Gilmore leaves readers with important questions about success, happiness, and the courage to change course. While it works perfectly as a standalone romance, its deeper themes will resonate long after the final page.
Final Thoughts
Clare Gilmore has crafted a meaningful exploration of modern love and ambition. Despite some minor pacing issues and plot conveniences, Perfect Fit succeeds as both a romance and a commentary on contemporary workplace culture. The author’s growth between her debut and this sophomore effort suggests an exciting career trajectory worth following.
The novel’s greatest strength lies in its ability to balance serious themes with romantic development, creating a story that entertains while prompting reflection on our own definitions of success and happiness.