In Kellan McDaniel’s YA debut, Till Death, readers are treated to a refreshingly unapologetic blend of romance, horror, and queer liberation that fearlessly bares its fangs at the systems that seek to oppress LGBTQ+ individuals. The novel follows two gay men – Howard, a high school senior yearning for escape, and George, a vampire frozen at nineteen who’s about to lose his longtime partner – as they find each other, fall in love, and ultimately choose violence in the face of a world that consistently chooses violence against them.
What begins as a tender romance between a mortal teenager and an immortal being transforms into a blood-soaked narrative of revenge that questions whether working within broken systems is enough for marginalized communities. The result is a provocative, darkly romantic tale that will divide readers – which seems to be precisely McDaniel’s intention.
Tale as Old as Time: A Fresh Take on Vampire Romance
McDaniel’s novel offers a contemporary twist on classic vampire fiction, drawing from both traditional tropes and more modern interpretations:
Howard is an academically successful but socially isolated senior at Wyndhurst Preparatory School, where he faces constant bullying while counting down the days until college. His only solace comes from volunteering at Spring Meadows retirement home and his friendship with Sue, the president of their school’s Queer Student Alliance.
George is a vampire who was turned in 1960 and has spent the past twenty years living with his partner James, who is now dying of dementia in the very retirement home where Howard volunteers. When the two meet, their connection is immediate – bonding over vintage fashion, classic films, and shared experiences of marginalization.
What makes this vampire romance distinctive is how McDaniel integrates contemporary queer politics with vampiric metaphor. George isn’t just a romantic figure but a living embodiment of queer history, having survived decades of persecution and loss. As Howard notes, “George has spent decades actually helping people,” actively participating in activism rather than merely enduring discrimination.
Blood-Red Flags: When Romance Takes a Darker Turn
The novel’s first half is deceptively sweet, focusing on the burgeoning relationship between Howard and George as they navigate their respective challenges. However, as external forces threaten their happiness, the narrative shifts dramatically into horror territory:
- When Howard is suspended for attacking a bully and fears for his college prospects
- When George faces homelessness after James’ daughter sells their house
- When police threaten to take George into custody, potentially exposing him to deadly sunlight
Rather than accepting these circumstances, the pair responds with escalating violence – first defensive, then proactive – targeting those they view as oppressors. This transformation from victims to vigilantes forms the heart of the novel’s most provocative theme: the idea that sometimes “progress” isn’t enough when the system itself is fundamentally broken.
What Bites and What Shines: A Critical Analysis
Strengths
- Authentic Voice: McDaniel writes with raw authenticity about the queer experience, particularly the frustration of navigating hostile systems. The QSA’s failed attempt to gain board approval for basic protections will resonate with anyone who has witnessed the slow pace of institutional change.
- Historical Context: Through George’s experiences across decades, the novel provides a compelling window into queer history. His reflections on the AIDS crisis, police raids, and early activism give the story emotional weight and historical significance.
- Intimate Scenes: The novel handles its sexual content with sensitivity and care. The first intimate scene between Howard and George, involving lingerie and enthusiastic consent, stands out as particularly well-crafted, balancing vulnerability with desire.
- Moral Complexity: Rather than providing easy answers, McDaniel forces readers to grapple with complex questions about justice, revenge, and how much violence can be justified in response to systemic oppression.
Weaknesses
- Pacing Issues: The novel’s shift from romance to revenge thriller happens somewhat abruptly, potentially leaving readers with tonal whiplash. The final third of the book accelerates considerably compared to the more languid earlier chapters.
- Underdeveloped Side Characters: While Howard and George are fully realized, supporting characters like Sue and Oma occasionally feel more like plot devices than fully-developed individuals, particularly as the story progresses.
- Limited Moral Perspective: The novel sometimes simplifies complex ethical questions by positioning certain characters as exclusively villainous. Some readers may find the straightforward endorsement of vigilante violence troubling without more nuanced exploration of alternatives.
- Resolution Rush: The ending feels somewhat hurried compared to the care taken in establishing the central relationship, leaving some emotional threads unresolved.
The Bite Behind the Book: Themes and Metaphors
Till Death by Kellan McDaniel sinks its teeth into several interconnected themes:
- Intergenerational Queer Connection: The relationship between Howard and George explores how queer experiences span generations, with both characters finding validation and understanding across age divides.
- Institutional Failure: Through the QSA’s futile attempts to work within the system, McDaniel highlights how institutions often fail to protect marginalized communities, raising questions about when radical action becomes necessary.
- Chosen Family: Both protagonists have been rejected by biological family members but find belonging elsewhere – Howard with his grandmother and George with James. Their union represents a new chosen family built on mutual understanding.
- Violence as Liberation: Perhaps most controversially, the novel posits that sometimes violence is a justified response to oppression – that when peaceful means of change consistently fail, direct action becomes not just understandable but necessary.
A Bloody Good Read? Final Verdict
Kellan McDaniel’s Till Death is not a comfortable read, nor is it meant to be. It’s a sharp-toothed, provocative tale that will challenge readers’ perceptions about justice, progress, and what marginalized communities owe to systems that consistently fail them.
The novel succeeds brilliantly in creating a compelling romance between its central characters while simultaneously questioning romantic conventions. Howard and George’s relationship feels authentic and emotionally resonant, even as their actions become increasingly extreme.
For readers familiar with McDaniel’s adult work published under K.M. Szpara (particularly Docile and First, Become Ashes), the author’s willingness to explore controversial themes will come as no surprise. Till Death continues this tradition, though with a more accessible YA approach that still refuses to pull punches.
Fans of darker queer narratives like Gideon the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir or All the White Spaces by Ally Wilkes will find much to appreciate in McDaniel’s unflinching approach. The novel also shares DNA with classic vampire narratives like Anne Rice’s Interview with the Vampire series while offering a distinctly contemporary perspective.
Overall, Till Death by Kellan McDaniel is a compelling, thought-provoking read that occasionally stumbles in execution but never in ambition. McDaniel has created a vampire romance that feels both timeless and urgently relevant, asking difficult questions about how far one should go when seeking justice in an unjust world.
The novel’s final message resonates long after the last page: sometimes love means having the courage to bare your fangs at a world that would rather see you docile and afraid. Whether readers agree with the protagonists’ choices or not, they certainly won’t forget them.
For Whom the Blood Flows: Recommended Readership
Till Death by Kellan McDaniel is best suited for:
- Mature young adult readers (16+) comfortable with explicit content and themes
- Fans of dark, morally complex queer narratives
- Readers interested in vampire fiction with contemporary political resonance
- Those who appreciate romance stories that evolve into something more challenging
However, sensitive readers should be aware of extensive content warnings for violence, blood, homophobia, transphobia, and vigilante justice. This is not your sparkly vampire romance – it’s a tale with real teeth and a willingness to draw blood.
In a publishing landscape that often sanitizes queer narratives to make them palatable for mainstream consumption, Till Death stands as a defiant reminder that sometimes the most authentic stories are the ones that refuse to play nice. McDaniel has crafted a provocative, memorable novel that will leave readers with plenty to sink their teeth into long after they’ve turned the final page.