Saturday, February 15, 2025

What the River Knows by Isabel Ibañez

Discover Egypt's ancient secrets in a tale of love, magic, and mystery.

Genre:
Despite some minor pacing issues and familiar plot elements, What the River Knows succeeds as an engaging historical fantasy that brings fresh elements to the genre. Ibañez has crafted an atmospheric adventure that skillfully balances romance, mystery, and magic while exploring themes of family, loyalty, and identity.

Top 5 This Week

Related Posts

Isabel Ibañez weaves an enchanting tale in What the River Knows, the first installment in her new Secrets of the Nile series. Set against the backdrop of 1880s Egypt, this YA historical fantasy masterfully blends archaeology, romance, and old world magic into an adventure that will captivate readers from start to finish. While the forthcoming sequel Where the Library Hides promises to continue the story, this opening volume stands strong on its own merits.

Story Overview

Nineteen-year-old Inez Olivera has grown up in the glittering society of Buenos Aires, yearning for her globe-trotting archaeologist parents who spend half of each year in Egypt. When news arrives of their tragic deaths in the desert, Inez inherits their fortune and a mysterious uncle who serves as her guardian. Armed with an ancient golden ring her father sent her before his death and her cherished sketchbooks, Inez defies propriety to sail alone to Cairo in search of answers.

Upon arrival, she discovers her mother is alive and claims her uncle Ricardo is involved in illegal artifact smuggling. As Inez tries to uncover the truth about her parents’ fate, she finds herself drawn into a dangerous quest involving Cleopatra’s lost tomb, old world magic, and her growing feelings for her uncle’s infuriatingly handsome assistant, Whitford Hayes.

Strengths & Notable Elements

Rich Historical Setting

Ibañez’s meticulous research shines through in her portrayal of 1880s Egypt under British colonial rule. The author brings Cairo to vivid life through sensory details – from the bustling Khan el-Khalili bazaar to the elegant Shepheard’s Hotel. The archaeological elements feel thoroughly researched, lending authenticity to the historical aspects while still maintaining the fantasy elements.

Magic System

The novel’s approach to magic is refreshingly unique. Rather than active spellcasting, magic exists as residual energy clinging to ancient objects, leaving traces of memories and emotions that certain people can access. This subtle take on magic enhances the historical elements rather than overshadowing them.

Character Development

Inez emerges as a compelling protagonist whose artistic talent and determination drive the story forward. Her character growth from sheltered society girl to independent young woman feels earned. The supporting cast is equally well-drawn, particularly Whit Hayes, whose layers are gradually revealed throughout the narrative.

Romance

The slow-burn romance between Inez and Whit proves to be one of the book’s strongest elements. Their initial antagonism evolves naturally into mutual respect and attraction, complicated by Whit’s secret noble status and arranged betrothal. The tension between them crackles with chemistry while remaining appropriate for the YA audience.

Areas for Improvement

Pacing Issues

The middle section of the novel occasionally drags, particularly during extended sequences of artifact cataloguing. While these details help establish the archaeological setting, they sometimes come at the expense of plot momentum.

Predictable Elements

Some plot twists, particularly regarding Inez’s mother’s true nature, may be obvious to seasoned readers. The “lost tomb” plotline treads familiar ground for anyone versed in Egyptian-set adventures.

Secondary Character Development

While the main characters are well-developed, some secondary characters like Inez’s cousin Elvira could have been more fully explored earlier in the narrative. Their eventual interactions add delightful energy to the final chapters.

Writing Style & Voice

Ibañez’s prose strikes an effective balance between period-appropriate formality and modern accessibility. Her backgrounds in visual art inform vivid descriptive passages, particularly in Inez’s artistic observations. The author seamlessly incorporrates Spanish phrases that add authenticity to Inez’s Argentinian heritage.

Cultural Elements & Representation

Following her work in Woven in Moonlight and Together We Burn, Ibañez continues to draw from her Bolivian heritage while expanding her scope to include both Argentinian and Egyptian cultural elements. The novel thoughtfully addresses British colonialism’s impact on Egyptian archaeology while centering Egyptian characters like Abdullah in pivotal roles.

Target Audience Appeal

What the River Knows will particularly resonate with readers who enjoy:

  • Historical fantasy with romantic elements
  • Archaeological adventures
  • Strong female protagonists
  • Slow-burn romance
  • Cultural diversity in YA literature
  • Egyptian mythology and history

Series Potential

The conclusion sets up intriguing possibilities for the sequel Where the Library Hides while still providing satisfying resolution to the main storylines. The established world and magic system offer rich ground for further exploration.

Final Verdict

Despite some minor pacing issues and familiar plot elements, What the River Knows succeeds as an engaging historical fantasy that brings fresh elements to the genre. Ibañez has crafted an atmospheric adventure that skillfully balances romance, mystery, and magic while exploring themes of family, loyalty, and identity.

Similar Recommendations

Readers who enjoy What the River Knows might also appreciate:

  • The Gilded Wolves by Roshani Chokshi
  • The Girl from Everywhere by Heidi Heilig
  • Ibañez’s previous works Woven in Moonlight and Together We Burn
  • These Violent Delights by Chloe Gong
  • The Lady Rogue by Jenn Bennett

About the Author

Isabel Ibañez draws inspiration from her Bolivian heritage in her writing. Her previous novels include Woven in Moonlight (2020), which earned recognition as a Time Magazine Top 100 Fantasy Book of All Time, and Together We Burn (2022). She brings her background as a visual designer to her vivid storytelling.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Popular Articles

Despite some minor pacing issues and familiar plot elements, What the River Knows succeeds as an engaging historical fantasy that brings fresh elements to the genre. Ibañez has crafted an atmospheric adventure that skillfully balances romance, mystery, and magic while exploring themes of family, loyalty, and identity.What the River Knows by Isabel Ibañez