There exists a peculiar alchemy in Sarah Beth Durst’s writing, one that transforms the mundane into the mythical while keeping both feet planted firmly in emotional truth. The Lost, Sarah Beth Durst’s debut adult novel now released in a fully updated and expanded edition with a brand-new ending, demonstrates this gift magnificently. The novel operates as both a literal fantastical adventure and a profound meditation on what it means to lose ourselves when we refuse to face our deepest fears.
Lauren Chase is running. Not toward something, but away from it—specifically, away from her dying mother and the unbearable weight of watching cancer slowly claim the only family she has left. What begins as a few hours of aimless driving transforms into an impossible imprisonment when Lauren’s car runs out of gas outside a desolate town called Lost, where the dust storms never clear and escape proves systematically futile.
Into the Void: Worldbuilding That Breathes
Durst constructs her strange little town with meticulous care, layering detail upon detail until Lost becomes as tangible as any real desert settlement. The geography itself functions as character: abandoned houses with foreclosure signs leaning against peeling paint, alleys crowded with feral children who watch newcomers with predatory curiosity, a diner where the waitress Victoria serves hostility alongside mediocre coffee. Everything in Lost was once loved and subsequently abandoned—luggage, dreams, wedding rings, houses expelled whole from the void, and most hauntingly, the people themselves.
The void surrounding Lost represents Durst’s most ambitious conceptual achievement. Neither simple dust storm nor traditional portal, it exists as something more unsettling: a physical manifestation of despair that consumes everything and everyone lacking sufficient hope to survive its embrace. Objects materialize from its depths without warning—golf balls, cameras, entire Cape houses launched like cosmic projectiles. The imagery carries genuine menace while remaining dreamlike, a balance not easily achieved.
Characters Who Cut Deep
Lauren herself emerges as a complicated protagonist, neither entirely sympathetic nor wholly frustrating. Her avoidance of her mother’s illness reads as devastatingly authentic to anyone familiar with anticipatory grief, that particular paralysis where facing reality feels more terrifying than any imagined alternative. Durst allows Lauren her flaws without excusing them, creating a character whose growth feels earned rather than imposed.
The supporting cast sparkles with distinctive personality despite the novel’s relatively contained scope:
- Peter, the Finder, presents an intriguing romantic interest—wild and beautiful with swirled tattoos across his chest, capable of rescuing lost souls from the void but incapable of keeping anyone from eventually leaving him
- Claire, a knife-wielding six-year-old in a tattered princess dress, guards her teddy bears with one hand and her survival with the other, embodying both the tragedy of abandoned children and remarkable resilience
- The Missing Man himself remains appropriately enigmatic, his motivations unfolding gradually through cryptic encounters and devastating revelations
The dynamic between Lauren, Peter, and Claire develops into something resembling found family, though Durst wisely avoids romanticizing their circumstances. These are damaged people clinging to each other because alternatives range from dangerous to nonexistent.
A Tale of Two Halves
Here the review must acknowledge where The Lost by Sarah Beth Durst occasionally stumbles. The novel’s pacing proves uneven, particularly during its middle sections. After the propulsive urgency of Lauren’s initial entrapment and the mob’s terrifying pursuit, the narrative settles into repetitive patterns: Lauren hides, Lauren scavenges, Lauren waits for Peter to return from searching. While this rhythm arguably mirrors the grinding monotony of being truly stuck, some readers may find their attention wandering during stretches where external conflict temporarily recedes.
Additionally, certain plot mechanics remain frustratingly opaque even by fantasy standards. The rules governing who can enter the void, what determines when someone becomes “found,” and precisely how Lauren’s connection to the Missing Man functions never crystallize into complete clarity. Durst opts for atmospheric suggestion over systematic explanation, a choice that enhances mystery but occasionally frustrates comprehension.
The romance, too, may divide readers. Peter and Lauren’s connection burns with genuine intensity, their scenes together crackling with tension and tenderness. However, Peter’s mercurial temperament—charming one moment, bitter and accusatory the next—occasionally tips from intriguing into exhausting. His repeated insistence that everyone abandons him, while psychologically consistent, creates emotional whiplash that not all readers will embrace.
The Heart’s True Geography
What elevates The Lost beyond its occasional structural weaknesses is Sarah Beth Durst’s unflinching examination of grief in all its ugly complexity. Lauren’s interstitial chapters—brief lists titled “Things I lost”—function as emotional gut-punches:
Things like “the future I was supposed to have” and “the potential for true love” appear alongside mundane items like headphones and pizza slices, capturing perfectly how loss refuses to observe proper hierarchies.
The mother-daughter relationship at the novel’s core achieves remarkable poignancy despite the mother appearing primarily through Lauren’s memories and guilt. When they finally reunite, their exchanges balance humor with devastating tenderness, two people determined to remain themselves even as time runs out. Mom’s irreverence—demanding Lauren provide her phone number to a handsome doctor while simultaneously dying—captures the fierce normalcy families maintain against encroaching darkness.
Prose That Sings Quietly
Durst writes with deceptive simplicity, her sentences clean and direct while carrying significant emotional freight. The first-person narration maintains Lauren’s distinctive voice throughout, occasionally sardonic, frequently afraid, always recognizably human. Descriptive passages achieve vivid specificity without purple excess: the void looking like “cotton, not dust particles suspended in the air,” the desert stretching away “as still as a painting.”
The expanded edition’s new ending reportedly addresses concerns readers had with the original conclusion. Without revealing specifics, the resolution now achieves greater emotional satisfaction while maintaining the ambiguity essential to the novel’s thematic concerns. Questions of what is real, what is imagined, and whether that distinction ultimately matters receive their due consideration.
Final Verdict: A Flawed Gem Worth Discovering
The Lost represents Sarah Beth Durst’s successful transition from young adult to adult fiction, demonstrating that her imaginative gifts translate powerfully across age categories. The novel delivers genuine emotional resonance, memorable characters, and worldbuilding that lingers in imagination long after the final page.
Imperfect it remains—pacing issues and occasionally murky mythology prevent it from achieving greatness—but for readers seeking fantasy that prioritizes emotional truth over systematic magic systems, The Lost offers substantial rewards. It understands something essential: that the things we lose matter less than whether we choose to keep searching.
Also By Sarah Beth Durst
Readers who connect with The Lost should explore Sarah Beth Durst’s extensive bibliography. Her sequel, The Missing, continues exploring this universe. The Queens of Renthia series (The Queen of Blood, The Reluctant Queen, The Queen of Sorrow) showcases her epic fantasy capabilities, while The Spellshop and The Enchanted Greenhouse represent her recent New York Times bestselling success in cozy fantasy. Ice, her retelling of “East of the Sun, West of the Moon,” shares The Lost‘s interest in women confronting impossible circumstances.
Similar Books You Might Enjoy
- The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern — Atmospheric magical realism with romance and mystery
- Piranesi by Susanna Clarke — Surreal setting, questions of identity and reality
- The Starless Sea by Erin Morgenstern — Labyrinthine worldbuilding, stories within stories
- House of Salt and Sorrows by Erin A. Craig — Gothic atmosphere, family secrets, romantic tension
- Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman — Hidden world beneath the ordinary, protagonist swept into strange circumstances
- The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue by V.E. Schwab — Bargains with mysterious forces, questions of memory and loss
- In the Labyrinth of Drakes by Marie Brennan — Fantasy adventure with strong female protagonist
- A Winter’s Promise by Christelle Dabos — Mysterious setting, atmospheric worldbuilding, romance